Calcium and Vitamin D for Fractures and Falls: 69 Trials, 153,902 People, and Very Little Difference

Calcium and vitamin D are two of the most common supplements in American kitchen cabinets, usually taken for bones. A large review in the BMJ this year pooled the randomized trials on that question, and I'd check any calcium or vitamin D routine against it.

Inside the BMJ review of 69 trials
A team from Montreal collected every randomized controlled trial they could find that compared calcium, vitamin D, or both against a placebo or no treatment in adults who were not taking prescription osteoporosis drugs [1]. That came to 69 trials and 153,902 participants. Most participants lived independently in the community (87%), and most were not at high risk of fractures or falls (73%).
The main outcome was any fracture, and the authors reported each result as a risk ratio. In case you haven't come across it, a risk ratio compares the risk in the supplement group with the risk in the comparison group, so 1.00 means no difference and 0.91 means a 9% lower risk. Each one comes with a 95% confidence interval, which is the range the true value probably falls in; when that range includes 1.00, the results are consistent with no difference at all. The authors also gave each result a certainty rating, their grade for how confident they are in the estimate.
For calcium alone, the risk ratio was 0.91 (95% confidence interval 0.81 to 1.01), rated moderate certainty. For vitamin D alone, it was 1.00 (0.95 to 1.06), rated high certainty: no difference. For calcium and vitamin D together, it was 0.91 (0.84 to 0.99), also high certainty. The researchers found the same pattern for hip fractures, spine fractures, the risk of falling, and the total number of falls, with little to no effect across the board.
The combined result came closest to a benefit, since the upper end of its confidence interval is 0.99, just under 1.00. The authors judged every effect against pre-set thresholds for how large an absolute drop in fractures would need to be to count as meaningful, and the combined supplement fell short of them. In other words, the reduction was too small to change outcomes for most people taking it. The authors also note that the trials included too few people at high risk, or living in residential care, to draw firm conclusions for those groups.
A large US trial, and the people these trials left out
The BMJ results are consistent with VITAL, a large US trial of vitamin D. VITAL randomly assigned 25,871 adults in midlife and older to 2,000 IU of vitamin D a day or a placebo and followed them for a median of 5.3 years [2]. Vitamin D did not lower total fractures (hazard ratio 0.98), non-spine fractures, or hip fractures. A hazard ratio works like the risk ratio above, except that it compares the rate of fractures over time in each group. The results were the same regardless of participants' starting vitamin D blood levels. In a separate VITAL analysis, the researchers found no reduction in falls either, including in people whose starting levels were below 50 nmol/L (20 ng/mL, in the units most US labs report) [3].
The VITAL researchers did not select participants for deficiency, low bone mass, or osteoporosis [2], and the average starting level in the falls analysis was 77 nmol/L, which is not deficient [3]. That means the VITAL results apply to the general population, the group most supplement marketing targets. They apply much less to someone with a documented deficiency.
Calcium supplements also have downsides, and I'd weigh those against a benefit this small. In a 2025 review of the trial evidence, Ian Reid of the University of Auckland summarized them: calcium supplements commonly cause digestive side effects, increase the risk of kidney stones, and in pooled trial data have been associated with a 10% to 20% higher risk of heart attack [4]. Calcium from food does not appear to carry that cardiac risk [4].
Bones are built from a whole diet and a body that moves
Osteoporosis affects about half of women and a fifth of men over 50 [5], so protecting bone is a practical question for many of my patients. From a naturopathic point of view, bone depends on everything that feeds it and everything that loads it, and a single pill is a small part of that.
Two researchers in Geneva summarized the nutrition evidence in a 2024 review [5]. They also list regular weight-bearing exercise among the basics of fracture prevention. If calcium intake is also adequate, then adequate protein is associated with lower fracture risk. Dairy foods, especially fermented ones like yogurt and kefir, are associated with lower hip fracture risk. At least five servings a day of fruit and vegetables, regular tea, and a Mediterranean-style pattern are also associated with lower fracture risk, possibly through their effects on the gut microbiome.
These are observational links. Observational means the researchers looked at what people already ate instead of assigning a diet, so a link like this cannot show that the food caused the lower risk. Taken together, they still make food the foundation I start with.
Reid also notes that estrogen and bisphosphonate medications reduce fractures without calcium needing to be added alongside them [4]. Bisphosphonates are a group of prescription medications used to treat osteoporosis. For someone with true osteoporosis, the decision about those medications belongs with their prescribing provider, and a supplement is no substitute for them.
Before you refill the calcium bottle
I'd use this review to rethink the default for healthy adults more than to change every individual plan. A few questions to bring to your next visit:
Is there a specific reason you take it? If your provider found a deficiency, or you have osteoporosis and take calcium or vitamin D as part of a prescribed plan, that is a different situation from the average in this review. Please do not stop prescribed treatment without talking to the person who manages it.
How much calcium does your food already provide? Dairy foods are a valuable source of both calcium and protein [5], and researchers have not found the higher heart attack risk with calcium from food that they found with supplements [4].
Do you have a history of kidney stones or heart disease? Both are reasons to review a calcium supplement with your provider [4].
What else might be raising your fall risk? Calcium and vitamin D did not reduce falls in these trials [1,3], so if falls worry you, the useful conversation is about everything else that affects balance and strength.
References
Massé O, Mercurio CM, Dupuis S, et al. Calcium, vitamin D, or combined supplementation to prevent fractures and falls: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ. 2026;393:e088050. PMID: 42161415. doi:10.1136/bmj-2025-088050. Original digest link: https://www.bmj.com/content/393/bmj-2025-088050
LeBoff MS, Chou SH, Ratliff KA, et al. Supplemental vitamin D and incident fractures in midlife and older adults. N Engl J Med. 2022;387(4):299-309. PMID: 35939577. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa2202106
LeBoff MS, Murata EM, Cook NR, et al. VITamin D and OmegA-3 TriaL (VITAL): effects of vitamin D supplements on risk of falls in the US population. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2020;105(9):2929-2938. PMID: 32492153. doi:10.1210/clinem/dgaa311
Reid IR. Calcium supplementation: efficacy and safety. Curr Osteoporos Rep. 2025;23(1):8. PMID: 39937345. doi:10.1007/s11914-025-00904-7 (Yggdrasil abstract library record)
Rizzoli R, Chevalley T. Nutrition and osteoporosis prevention. Curr Osteoporos Rep. 2024;22(6):515-522. PMID: 39322861. doi:10.1007/s11914-024-00892-0 (Yggdrasil abstract library record)
This article is for education only and is not medical advice. If you take calcium, vitamin D, or osteoporosis medication as part of a plan from your provider, please talk with them before making any change.
If this resonates with what you're experiencing and you'd like to explore a naturopathic approach, book a consultation with our clinic.




Comments