Traditional Navajo Meals and Heart Failure: What the MUTTON-HF Trial Found

"Food is medicine" gets used so much that it can start to sound like a slogan. It is a phrase I believe in, and I also want to see it tested the same way we test a new drug. In September, a randomized trial from the Navajo Nation put it to that kind of test in people with heart failure, and the meal program came out ahead.

What the MUTTON-HF trial found
The trial is called MUTTON-HF, short for Medically Utilized Tailored Traditional Foods to Optimize Nutrition in Heart Failure [1]. Researchers worked with Diné (Navajo) community members to design a meal program built on traditional Diné foods and recipes, with Native produce and meat sourced locally [2]. The meals were also medically tailored, meaning they were planned around the nutritional needs of people with heart failure.
The study enrolled 206 adults with heart failure at two Indian Health Service sites in rural Navajo Nation [1]. Everyone had been hospitalized or seen in an emergency department within the previous year. Half received the meal program for eight weeks, and half received usual dietary advice. This was an open-label trial, so participants knew which group they were in.
Over 90 days, 40.6% of people in the meal group were hospitalized or visited the emergency department, compared with 57.0% of the usual-care group [1]. Most of that difference came from fewer hospital stays: 12.3% versus 26.0%. Hospitalizations for heart failure specifically fell from 13.0% to 3.8% [1]. People in the meal group also reported better heart failure quality of life and more food security, and they had lower financial strain, weight, and blood pressure by the end of the eight weeks [1].
Before this trial, the same team conducted a small pilot with 20 patients to make sure the program could work in communities spread over a radius of more than 136 kilometers (about 85 miles). Ninety percent of the weekly meal boxes reached patients, and the number of people who were food secure rose from 8 to 17 [3].
What other trials have found
Medically tailored meals for heart failure have had mixed results in earlier trials. In a 2026 trial in Dallas, researchers randomized 150 people recently hospitalized for heart failure to medically tailored meals, fresh produce, or usual care [4]. Food delivery went smoothly and patients liked it, yet it did not reduce heart failure readmissions or emergency visits over 90 days. The food groups did have better results on a broader composite score [4].
In California, a larger 2022 trial randomized almost 2,000 adults with heart failure, diabetes, or kidney disease after a hospital discharge [5]. Ten weeks of medically tailored meals did not lower overall hospitalizations. In exploratory analyses, the meal group had fewer heart failure hospitalizations and lower mortality, and the authors were clear that those findings need confirmation [5].
In a 2024 systematic review of medically tailored meals in heart failure, researchers found six studies [6]. Sodium-restricted meals reduced 90-day readmissions in one study and showed a trend toward fewer readmissions in another. The authors concluded that larger, adequately powered trials are needed [6].
Why culturally rooted food may make a difference
The authors did not test why MUTTON-HF did better than some earlier programs, so any explanation is a hypothesis. Still, I think two features of this program might be part of the reason.
First, the program addressed food insecurity directly. The authors describe nutrition insecurity as a major cause of poor heart health in Indigenous communities, and the trial measured improvements in food security alongside the clinical outcomes [1]. Advice to eat less salt can do very little if the nearest grocery store is an hour away or money is tight.
Second, the food was familiar, and it came from the participants' own culture. The program was designed with the community rather than for it, and the pilot measured cultural connectedness as one of its outcomes [3]. Food that fits someone's culture and daily life can be easier to keep eating, which might explain why a meal program would succeed in one place and not in another. To me, this is food as medicine in a very literal form: the meal supports the heart, and the way it is grown and shared supports the person.
Bringing these ideas into your own kitchen with heart failure
You do not need to be part of a research study to apply some of these ideas:
Look at access before willpower. If cost, distance, or energy makes healthy eating hard, say so to your care team. Some hospitals and clinics can connect people with food programs or social workers.
Build on the foods you grew up with. Many traditional cuisines already center on vegetables, beans, grains, and simply prepared meats. A dietitian can help you adapt family recipes to fit your heart's needs rather than replacing them.
Ask about medically tailored meals. Some insurers and health systems may offer them after a hospital stay, particularly for heart failure.
Keep your cardiology plan in place. Food works alongside your medications and monitoring. Before you make any big change to salt, fluid, or potassium, ask your cardiologist how it fits with your heart failure treatment, since those changes can interact with it.
References
Eberly LA, George C, Sandman S, et al. An Indigenous Food Is Medicine Intervention: The MUTTON-HF Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Intern Med. 2026;186(9):1077-1087. PMID 42507456. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2026.2879. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42507456/
Eberly LA, George C, Sandman S, et al. MUTTON-HF: Rationale and Design of a Study of an Indigenous Food is Medicine Intervention. Circ Heart Fail. 2026;19(4):e014013. PMID 41766529. doi:10.1161/CIRCHEARTFAILURE.125.014013
Eberly LA, George C, Sandman S, et al. Feasibility of an Indigenous Food Is Medicine Program for Patients With Heart Failure in Rural Navajo Nation: The MUTTON-HF Nonrandomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Netw Open. 2026;9(2):e2556117. PMID 41649816. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2025.56117
Pandey A, Keshvani N, Coellar JD, et al. Food Supplementation in Patients Hospitalized for Heart Failure: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Cardiol. 2026;11(6):564-573. PMID 41949846. doi:10.1001/jamacardio.2026.0435
Go AS, Tan TC, Horiuchi KM, et al. Effect of Medically Tailored Meals on Clinical Outcomes in Recently Hospitalized High-Risk Adults. Med Care. 2022;60(10):750-758. PMID 35972131. doi:10.1097/MLR.0000000000001759
McIntosh N, Billingsley H, Hummel SL, Mills WL. Medically Tailored Meals in Heart Failure: A Systematic Review of the Literature, 2013-2023. J Card Fail. 2025;31(6):939-950. PMID 39674490. doi:10.1016/j.cardfail.2024.10.446
This post is for education only and is not medical advice. Heart failure needs ongoing care from a cardiologist or primary care provider. Please do not change your diet, fluid intake, or medications without talking with your care team, and seek urgent care for sudden weight gain, worsening shortness of breath, or chest pain.
If this resonates with what you're experiencing and you'd like to explore a naturopathic approach, book a consultation with our clinic.




Comments